The Mysterious Island: Survival by Method
Jules Verne's castaway novel treats a Pacific island as a workshop, and its patience is both its subject and its price.
Five men and a dog fall out of the sky. That is how The Mysterious Island opens, in a balloon caught by a storm over the Pacific, and the first pages are pure alarm: short shouts traded in the dark as ballast goes over the side and the sea comes up to meet the car. It is the most breathless the book will ever be, and the reader should know this going in.
“Are we rising again?” “No. On the contrary.” “Are we descending?” “Worse than that, captain! we are falling!” “For Heaven’s sake heave out the ballast!”
Chapter 1
Once the survivors reach land, the novel settles into what it is really about. This is not chiefly an adventure of pursuit and escape. It is a book about people with nothing making everything, step by patient step, and the pleasure it offers is the pleasure of watching a problem solved correctly.
A robinsonade run by an engineer
The organising mind belongs to Cyrus Harding, an engineer, and the book takes his temperament as its own. Asked where to begin, he answers that they will begin at the beginning, and Verne means it with a thoroughness that can be exhausting. The castaways have not merely lost their comforts; they lack the very means of making the means.
They did not possess even the tools necessary for making tools, and they were not even in the condition of nature, who, “having time, husbands her strength.” They had no time
Chapter 13
From that starting point the group works metals, pottery and cloth up from raw minerals, clay and fibre. Verne clearly delights in the sequence, and readers who share that delight — anyone with a fondness for how things are made — will find the book generous. Readers who came for chase and danger will spend long stretches waiting.
Texture and companions
The prose is plain and declarative, fond of exact dates and of naming everything the settlers name: the Mercy for their river, Granite House for their home, Prospect Heights for their lookout. The effect is of a careful log kept by a competent man. It is rarely lyrical and never in a hurry.
The characters are drawn broadly and hold their assigned notes. Pencroft the sailor is the book's heart, quick to grief and quick to joy; his running lament over having only a half-pound of tobacco is the closest the novel comes to comedy. Neb, a former servant, is given the book's most physical expressions of feeling, and here the writing shows its age most plainly: his joy at the vessel's return is offered as spectacle rather than interiority.
As to Neb in his joy, he began to dance, to twirl round, clapping his hands and shouting, “Oh! my master!” A more touching pantomime than the finest discourse.
Chapter 15
An Indian reader will recognise that phrasing for what it is — the racial condescension of the period, worn on the surface. It does not sink the book, but it is there, and an honest catalogue should say so.
Who it rewards
Danger does arrive. There are convicts on the island, and one chapter opens on Herbert, the youngest, shot and carried senseless while Pencroft beats his head against a wall in grief. These episodes are sharp and well handled, but they are islands in a calm sea of industry, not the tide the book runs on.
- Rewarding for: readers who like process, competence and the slow accumulation of a made world; anyone who enjoys watching capable people solve a hard problem correctly.
- A trial for: readers who want sustained tension, psychological depth, or characters who surprise themselves.
- Dated: the treatment of the servant Neb, and a general faith in ingenuity that reads as very much of its century.
- Not dated: the clarity of the sentences, and the genuine satisfaction of the engineering itself.
Taken on its own terms, The Mysterious Island is a satisfying and unusually patient book: less a thriller than an ode to human resourcefulness, told at the pace of the work it describes. Bring patience to it and it repays you; bring only a hunger for peril and you will be checking how many chapters remain.
The book, free to read
More from the reading desk
Browse all →
Getting Started with Joseph Conrad
A guide to the Polish-British master of English prose for readers meeting his work for the first time.
An Introduction to Edgar Rice Burroughs
A prolific American writer of adventure, science fiction and fantasy, and the creator of Tarzan and John Carter.
Jack London: An Introduction for New Readers
An American writer of frontier adventure, animal stories and political fiction, and where a newcomer might begin.
Seven Adventures from the XtreamFm Library
A reading list from the Adventure shelf, from a Michigan riverbank to the chessboards of Mars.