Plato's Protagoras: A Sparring Match Disguised as Dinner Conversation
A dialogue that begins as a tutorial on virtue and devolves into competitive poetry criticism, revealing Socrates at his most evasive.
Protagoras is one of Plato's longer and more theatrical dialogues, set in the crowded house of Callias, a wealthy Athenian who collects Sophists the way others collect art. The premise is simple: young Hippocrates wants to study with Protagoras, the most famous teacher in Athens, and Socrates agrees to introduce him—but only after interrogating what exactly Protagoras teaches. What follows is not a lecture but a drawn-out sparring match, where the ostensible topic is whether virtue can be taught, but the real action is in the evasions, interruptions, and rhetorical manoeuvres of two men who refuse to give ground.
The Shape of the Argument
The dialogue begins briskly, with Socrates recounting the visit to a companion. The framing device—Socrates as narrator—gives the whole thing a novelistic quality, complete with character sketches of the assembled Sophists and their admirers. But once the philosophical conversation begins, the pace slows dramatically. Protagoras delivers a long, mythic speech about the origins of virtue, complete with gods and Titans. Socrates responds with a close reading of a poem by Simonides that occupies a substantial stretch of the middle section. The poem analysis feels like a detour, and it is meant to: Socrates openly admits he would rather return to the original question.
I wish Protagoras either to ask or answer as he is inclined; but I would rather have done with poems and odes, if he does not object, and come back to the question about which I was asking you at first, Protagoras, and by your help make an end of that. The talk about the poets seems to me like...
That line captures the frustration simmering beneath the polite surface. Both men know they are stalling. Protagoras prefers set speeches; Socrates insists on short questions and answers. The method itself becomes the battleground, and the reader is left to judge who is being more reasonable—or more obstinate.
Who This Rewards and Who It Exhausts
This is not a dialogue for readers looking for clean answers or inspirational uplift. Protagoras never quite concedes, and Socrates never quite proves his point. The conclusion, if it can be called that, is ironic: both men seem to have argued themselves into positions they did not hold at the start. Readers who enjoy watching skilled debaters fence, who appreciate the comedy of intellectual vanity, and who do not mind a text that withholds resolution will find much to admire here. The presence of Alcibiades and Critias—figures whose later lives would end in scandal and tyranny—adds a layer of dramatic irony for those familiar with Athenian history.
But the dialogue will bore anyone hoping for a straightforward lesson in ethics or a tidy Socratic takedown. The poetry section, in particular, is a slog, and Socrates himself acknowledges as much. The translation by Benjamin Jowett is clear and fluid, though it carries the slight formality of nineteenth-century English, which oddly suits the mannered social setting. What dates the text is not the language but the assumption that an educated reader will recognise every allusion to Homer and Hesiod. What does not date is the spectacle of two intelligent people talking past each other while a room full of onlookers pretends to follow along.
Protagoras is best read as a social drama with philosophical content, rather than the other way around. It is a portrait of intellectual celebrity, of the performance required to maintain a reputation, and of Socrates as an agitator who delights in making things difficult. If you come to it expecting wisdom, you may leave frustrated. If you come expecting a sharply observed scene, you will not be disappointed.
The book, free to read
More from the reading desk
Browse all →
Timaeus: Plato's Cosmos, Filtered Through Jowett
Plato's account of the making of the world, wrapped in a long introduction that spends as much time explaining the book as the book spends on the cosmos.
Empire, Settlement, and Self-Government: A Reading List for Independence Day
Eight books from the collection, read in a line that runs from the machinery of empire to the arguments a new nation makes for itself.
Henry Graham Dakyns: The Voice of Xenophon in English
A British translator who brought the histories, dialogues and treatises of the ancient Greek writer Xenophon into readable English.
An Introduction to Oscar Wilde
A guide to the Irish playwright, poet and essayist for readers meeting his work for the first time, with a suggestion on where to begin.